Arsenic and Old Lace
By Joseph Kesserling
March 21 – April 6, 2024
American Classic Series
Mainstage | Thursday – Saturday | 
This classic American comedy centers on the eccentric Brewster family, who live in a quaint Brooklyn neighborhood. When their nephew Mortimer visits from out of town, he discovers that his sweet, elderly aunts have been poisoning lonely old men and burying them in the basement. Chaos ensues as Mortimer tries to keep his aunts out of trouble, deal with his crazy relatives and figure out what to do with the bodies.
Preview: March 20
| Martha Brewster | Alyssa Hickman Grove |
| Abby Brewster | Betsy West |
| Teddy Brewster | Jim Nelson |
| Elaine Harper | Katie Plott |
| Mortimer Brewster | Bryan Harper |
| The Rev. Dr. Harper | Kelly Ward |
| Officer Klein | Skyler DeVries |
| Jonathan Brewster | David Hanson |
| Mr. Witherspoon/Mr. Gibs | Randy Honaker |
| Officer Brophy | Trevor Blair |
| Officer O’Hara | Robert A. Easton |
| Dr. Einstein | Isaac Maltby |
| Lieutenant Rooney | Thomas J Cowan |
| Director | Anne Stewart Mark |
| Stage Manager | Kalista Vordos |
| Asst. Director | Ellie Otis |
| Set Designer | Halee Rasmussen |
| Lighting Designer | Spencer Brown |
| Sound Designer | Joe Killian |
| Costume | Shannon McCullock |
| Wig & Make-Up | Erin McCullock |
| Props Master | Maire Nelligan |